I too have a outstanding order from "wish upon a starfish". We have all been duped by this lady into sending her money and never getting our orders!
I won't buy anything ever again from etsy nor will I use paypal! How do they let people like this join their site? I am sure that this started from the beginning of when she joined. And yes, she had a timelinw outside the window of getting your money refunded.
Paypal told me to go to my bank to get my money back! They have not yet refunded my money, nor do i think it will ever be refunded.
Reason of review: Order processing issue.
Monetary Loss: $31.